Can I answer this one after the 49ers-Patriots game? There’s no question that Manning has played well but the Broncos really haven’t impressed with their victories. If Brady can add wins over Manning, as well as the teams with the best records in either conference, I think you have to go with him. That might be over simplifying it, but let’s talk after Brady has gone against two of the best defenses in the NFL and then it will be a lot more clear.
It looks like the MVP race is going to come down to Manning vs. Brady. Who do you think will be more deserving when the voting starts?