Well, here’s where me and Coach BB disagree, I think, but I’d use a first rounder if the right guy is there with the explosion and array of moves necessary to win as a pass rusher in the NFL.
Here’s my argument, BB has said that the nickel corner is essentially considered a starter now. And that’s backed up by the fact that the traditional “sub” defense is now actually the base.
That’s not to say that this sub defense means it’s an all-out pass rush defense. You very well might not have your designated pass rusher in there, especially on early downs, even if you have five defensive backs on the field.
Still, the DPR is the next guy into the mix, and while you can’t technically call him a “three-down” player, he’s going to have a significant impact on a significant percentage of the defensive snaps.
When you look at what the Patriots defense has stunk at in recent years, it’s clear.
In the last four seasons, the Pats are the worst defense in the NFL giving up 20+ passes and on third down. Those are critical areas.
Those two situations speak directly to the DPR as I see it and these stats are inexcusable. It’s pretty much a miracle that the Pats have won as much as they have, but what has saved them is their red zone defense (esp. 2013) and TFB.
So that’s why I think a DPR is worth a first round pick. They will be an impact player at a position of extreme need. Will they play a ton against a run-first team? Maybe not, but against the elite QB’s of the league they might not come off the field.